Caputo's Pizza

I have been coming to Caputos for a long time now. All their food is absolutely amazing! I must recommend the Brushetta Pizza, one of my favorites. Their meals are plentiful & the prices are very reasonable! The owner Mark always has a smile & is ready to serve his customers. Jason, Paul, Rob & Arlene are just a few of the outstanding employees that are prompt & courteous! I urge everyone to stop by Caputos, you will definitely love all their meals!

I love this guy. I wish I could’ve worked for him, when I had a chance. Great pizza great food very hard-working. Individual always consistent.

Food is always super great, even after areiving 1 hr late i highly recommend! This was #4 on their Daily Specials list :)

Great pizza, sandwiches, and the people working there are always friendly.

Best by-the-slice pizzeria in Middletown! Lots of great choices, and the flavors are from fresh ingredients. A must if in town

First time ordering here, did take out. We got a plain pie, garbage pie, and chicken fingers with fries. The plain pie reminded me of Queens, so that's a huge win. The garbage pie was tasty, but needed a little more time. I recommend ordering it "well done". The chicken fingers and fries are kid approved 100% as they were gone before I could get a picture. Overall, probably the best pizza in 10940 and 10941 that I have tried so far.

I have refused since 2013ish when I 1st started eating here, to ever like any other pizza place at all. Mark is amazing... They catered my baby shower 1 1/2 yrs ago - everything was so good, put together perfect, & done right on time seamlessly. He made the process so easy for me (I planned my entire shower by myself & this was so helpful). I also recently got 8 personal pies worth of dough to fly to FL with & my FL friends got to taste REAL NY pizza for the 1st time. They were beyond impressed. Mark called me & step by step walked my through how to travel with them & make them. He was worried about the flight, but they made it down there & were absolutely DELISH!!!! The garlic butter wings are my fav & I get them frequently - crispy, juicy, & flavorful. The desserts are always fresh, as are the other ingredients used. This time I got Nonnas meatballs for the 1st time (omg delish) & their fried ravioli - which I am so picky about anytime I order them anywhere, but here they were perfectly CRISPY, not too moist, & the sauce was heavenly. 1000 out of 10 recommend to EVERYONE & tell them this is LEGIT the best in all of the upstate tristate area. I fight people who say otherwise because what are you eating if it isn’t CAPUTOS!! I’ve been a ride or die since their first location. Here until the end because they’ve NEVER switched up! *original review left on TikTok, so good google needs it too*

Honestly by far the greatest pizza place I’ve gone to in Middletown! I always order from here whether it’s pasta, ice cream, Stromboli, wings everything is delicious. Mind you this is a size small Stromboli. I had leftovers for lunch the next day. And the wings had surprisingly a lot meat on them. I’m so happy this place is right around the corner from my house. 10/10 would recommend coming to eat here.